OUR TEAM
For nearly 25 years, The Total Look has been a cornerstone of the Presque Isle community. Owned and operated by Sheila Cunningham, our salon is dedicated to providing a professional, inclusive, and welcoming environment for everyone who walks through our doors. We pride ourselves on being a tight-knit, team-oriented salon where our stylists work together to ensure every client leaves happy. Our comprehensive services include: Expert Hair Care: Precision haircuts, custom colors, and specialized texture services. Nail Services: Professional manicures and pedicures to complete your look. Additional Amenities: Tanning services and facial waxing. At The Total Look, we believe that education never ends. Our team is committed to continuous learning to stay at the forefront of the latest industry trends and techniques. We love serving the wonderful people of Presque Isle and are honored to be your local destination for all things beauty.
Sheila Cunningham
With 37 years of experience in the industry, my name is Sheila Cunningham, and I am the proud owner and operator of The Total Look. Over nearly four decades, I have built my career on a foundation of compassion and appreciation for every guest who walks through our doors. While I specialize in precision haircuts, custom colors, and perms, my true passion lies in the atmosphere we’ve created. I pride myself on fostering a supportive team environment, encouraging "my girls" to work together to ensure every client feels genuinely welcome and valued. For me, it’s about more than just great hair; it’s about serving our community with excellence and heart.
Katie-Anne Donnelly
With 17 years of experience—16 of those spent right here at The Total Look—I’ve turned my passion for hair into a lifelong career. My name is Katie-Anne Donnelly, and I truly love what I do because I love the people I get to serve every day. I specialize in custom haircuts and colors, but I also have a deep appreciation for the science of texture. Whether you are looking for a classic perm or a sleek, certified Keratin smoothing treatment, I am dedicated to helping you achieve a look that makes you feel confident and refreshed. For me, it’s not just about the hair; it’s about the connection and the joy of helping my clients look and feel their absolute best.
Allison Pelletier
With 15 years of dedicated experience, my name is Allison Pelletier, and my journey in the beauty industry began right here at The Total Look. As a veteran technician, I’ve had the privilege of leading two nail tech apprenticeships, sharing my passion and expertise with the next generation of professionals. I am certified in OPI Powder Perfection and specialize in high-quality manicures, pedicures, and acrylics. However, I believe my work goes far beyond just "pretty nails." I am most proud of the specialized care I provide to those facing health or physical challenges. Whether I am assisting the elderly, diabetic clients, or individuals with limited physical capacity, I find deep fulfillment in helping people manage their hand and foot health when they cannot do so themselves. I truly love what I do because I love helping people feel better—not just in how they look, but in how they feel every day.
Jada Gilman
A graduate of the Aveda Institute, Jada Gilman joined The Total Look shortly after earning her license in 2023. Jada has a passion for creating seamless, 'lived-in' hair color, specializing in custom highlighting techniques for both blondes and brunettes. Committed to evolving her craft, she is currently completing certifications in lash lifting, brow lamination, and tinting. Jada is dedicated to providing a comprehensive beauty experience and looks forward to welcoming new clients into her chair.
Grace Tarr
Hi! I’m Grace Tarr, and I’ve been styling hair since 2019. I’ve found my creative home at The Total Look, where I get to do what I love every single day alongside an amazing team. Connecting with people is at the heart of everything I do. Whether I’m working on precision cutting, custom coloring, or texture perms, my goal is always to make you feel like the best version of yourself. I have a special passion for bridal and updo styling—there is nothing quite like the joy of helping a client feel stunning on their big day! My eye for color actually started back in hair school, where I won a CHI color contest that sent me on an unforgettable trip to Houston, Texas. I can’t wait to welcome you into my chair and help you achieve your hair goals!